The project at 516 Forward St, three times the size of the previous home, will continue after a fallen wall triggered a new coastal development permit.
The La Jolla Development Permit Review committee approved a permit to expand a home at 516 Forward St from 1,075 to 3,699 square feet.
The Bird Rock project is already under construction, with work mostly finished on the partial demolition, remodel and addition of a second story to the existing one-story single dwelling unit.
The tripling of the square footage did not trigger the need for a coastal development permit – and local review – until rains led one wall to crumble; Losing a wall meant the project would have to rebuild more than 50% of the original walls, a threshold that requires a CDP.
DPR heard the project Aug 12 and asked applicant Federico Escobedo to return Aug 19 with more information including a comparison of the preexisting home to the proposed renovation and photos with neighboring houses, as adjacent residents raised concerns about the size of the new build.

“This thing is built already,” DPR trustee Greg Jackson said Aug 19. “The city [of San Diego] is probably not going to say, ‘Come in and demolish it.’ … This is one of those awkward cases where … we suddenly have to review something.”
Property-adjacent neighbor Elijah Schneider spoke at both DPR meetings about the project’s size: “It feels absolutely massive,” he said Aug 19.
Schneider, who has privacy concerns related to the home’s size, added the project does not conform with community character.
Schneider and his wife moved to Bird Rock, he said, as out of all the La Jolla neighborhoods, “it’s the character [and] the community that make Bird Rock so special.”
Neighbors on the other side of 516 Forward, John Newsam and Sharon Wampler, echoed that the new home does not fit with the neighborhood’s style and sizes.
“The only thing I can tell you is that we are exercising the rights to build,” Escobedo said. “We are within the code [and floor-to-area ratio], we are under the coverage restrictions, and we are within the height limits.”
“La Jolla, including Bird Rock, is zoned for much larger structures and much more density than has been built historically,” Jackson said. “If we think that it should be zoned for less density and smaller structures, the right avenue is to try to get the city to change those zoning rules.”
With regard to Escobedo’s planned curb cut and driveway on Forward Street, DPR Chair Brian Will noted such curb cuts are not allowed on narrow lots served by alleys, as this one is.
“We want to keep that curb cut, if possible,” Escobedo said, though city staff have recommended the project move forward without it.
A motion to approve the project, consistent with staff’s recommendation to eliminate the curb cut and driveway, passed with trustee John Shannon opposed and Jackson, acting as chair during Will’s brief absence, abstaining.