The La Jolla Shores Planned District Advisory Board objected to the size of the planned home as compared with others in the neighborhood.
A proposal to demolish one home and build a larger one at 1835 Spindrift Dr received unanimous denial from the La Jolla Shores Planned District Advisory Board June 17 as the board members felt the plans are too large for the lot.
The plans call for the demolition of a 3,214 square-foot home and construction of a new, 5,482 square-foot, two-story residence with pool and subterranean basement, six-car parking garage and accessory dwelling unit.
The lot size is 7,120 square feet, making the floor-area ratio of the proposed build 0.77.
The proposal is a redesign of earlier plans, based on neighbor feedback, and includes revisions including shifting the garage entrance to the alley and varying the roof styles to reduce bulk and scale, according to architect Taal Safdie of Safdie Rabines Architects.
Despite the design team’s willingness to work with the neighbors, “unfortunately, the project is still way too big,” said attorney Julie Hamilton, representing Spindrift neighbors.
The surrounding houses have an average FAR of 0.39, she said, with only one other home within 300 feet having as high an FAR as the proposed house.
The project is also incompatible with the bulk and scale of the rest of the community, Hamilton said.
“It’s not a massive house, it’s a small lot,” she said. The project is “simply too big.”
The Shores is “a changing community,” Safdie said, adding that many of the existing single-level houses have been or will be replaced with two-level houses “that excuse what is considered the average.”
The Shores Planned District Advisory Board members agreed the bulk and scale of the project were misaligned with the neighborhood.
The lack of second-story step backs, board member Herbert Lazerow said, “is a problem.”
Additionally, he said, the house “is so far out of character with the houses in the vicinity [and] it simply appears overbearing.”
“This FAR is too big,” board member Sherri Lightner said.
Lightner, along with board member Kathleen Neil, added the lack of sufficient landscaping is also a concern.
Board member Suzanne Weissman cited a lack of neighborhood notice for the project in her objections.
Neil moved to deny the project based on its nonconformity with the La Jolla Shores PDO and noted the plans need additional landscaping, a reduction in bulk and scale and proper noticing; the motion passed unanimously.



