Planning group approves Princess Street beach trail design

The 7-5 vote split trustees on the merits of reopening a long-closed access point adjacent to private homes during a lengthy discussion.

Designs for a reopened Princess Street beach access trail narrowly received La Jolla Community Planning Association approval Jan 9, with trustees weighing in on the debate between preserving beach access and protecting sensitive environments and private property from reckless behavior.

The scope of work at 7957 Princess St. calls for a five-foot wide stair structure made primarily of wood components with landings and metal stairs the last few feet down to the beach.

The La Jolla Development Permit Review Committee unanimously forwarded the project on to LJCPA last year after two reviews, with DPR members asking for extra consideration for management and security before construction moves forward.

The item was pulled from LJCPA’s consent agenda Dec 5 by adjacent neighbor Mike Reynolds and land use consultant Chandra Slaven over environmental and other concerns.

That particular coastal access point has had a convoluted history; the trail closed in 1979 due to a previous landowner’s privatization of the trail.

Ure and Dianne Kretowicz who bought their trail-adjacent home in 1994, have been involved in litigation with government agencies over the easement condition since 1999; the Coastal Commission ruled in 2012 the gate was on public land and mandated its reopening.

Ure Kretowicz and Reynolds have expressed heavy opposition to the plans during DPR reviews, citing concerns with security and liability. 

Pam Heatherington, acting director of the Environmental Center of San Diego, which has shepherded the new designs, said Jan 9 that ECDO has taken steps to address the residents’ concerns.

The plans now include a new or modified fence across the trail entrance, which will be open one half hour before sunrise to one half hour after sunset, Heatherington said. 

Loitering and noise prevention will be handled similarly to any beach access point.

ECDO is also willing “ to work with neighbors to incorporate reasonable measures [such as] electrical power and mounting locations for cameras or lights,” Heatherington said, “but it will require buy-in from the neighbors … [and] approval by the California Coastal Commission.”

With regard to liability, Heatherington said “it is not required of us to indemnify the landowner. If all coastal access trails needed to be indemnified, we would likely not have coastal access.”

Heatherington’s updates failed to assuage Kretowicz and Reynolds, who each reiterated their concerns.

The impacts to the residents of Princess Street would involve blocking ingress and egress, along with emergency vehicle access, Kretowicz said. 

Additionally, the current insurance policy leaves him vulnerable to defense costs in case of a claim, he said. 

“The other issue is ongoing maintenance,” Kretowicz added. “Nowhere in the plan do they talk about how they’re going to handle trash and … how they’re going to handle graffiti, vandalism, repairs and monitoring.”

The reopened beach access is “not going to be a safe access for the general public,” Reynolds said, citing changing marine tides and unstable cliffs. 

Members of the public spoke both in favor and against the project, furthering the tension between wanting to restore and preserve beach access and protect sensitive ecology while preventing an increase in carelessness.

CPA trustees then took up the debate.

“This could fundamentally change the character of a neighborhood, and I don’t think we should be hasty to endorse it, even though we know coastal access is a wonderful thing,” trustee Brian Will said.

CPA President Harry Bubbins, however, directed trustees to focus only on the design of the public access point. 

A motion to recommend approval of the project passed 7-5, with trustees Patrick Ahern, Larry Davidson, Greg Jackson, Will and Brian Williams voting against and Bubbins abstaining as is customary.

© lajolla.ca

COMMUNITY

Locally Loved

Your guide to community updates, neighborhood projects and restaurant news around La Jolla.

WEEKLY SCHEDULE

What's Happening

Live music, local theater and events to stay active.


View events calendar
Submit a local event listing
LIVE COVE STATUS

Tides & Sunset

Loading tides...
Loading ocean temp...
Loading sunset...
View tide tables
SUNDAY MARKET

La Jolla Open Aire Market

Join the community in supporting local schools and farmers every Sunday at Girard and Genter.

NEWSLETTER

Straight to Your Inbox

Join more than 10,000 locals who get our curated La Jolla news and events digests weekly.

Subscribe

Elisabeth Frausto

Elisabeth Frausto has been reporting on and writing about La Jolla since 2019. With dozens of local and state journalism awards to her name, Elisabeth knows the industry as well as she knows her community. When she’s not covering all things 92037, you’ll find her with coffee in hand staring at the sea.

You May Be Interested

Subscribe

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Everything happening in La Jolla, sent right to your inbox!

Enjoying our content?

Your contribution helps support our small local team of journalists in continuing to bring you quality content and news about La Jolla.

Most Recent

  • Tags
  • 1720 Torrey Pines Road
  • 2734 Bordeaux Ave
  • 7301 Encelia Dr
  • AAI-Steinman Award
  • Accessory Dwelling Units
  • Accursio Lota
  • Activism
  • Activities in La Jolla
  • Advocacy
  • Alessandro Sette

Dinner served with the waves

Win a $250 gift card to San Diego’s most iconic dining room, where the tide rolls right up to your table.

Prime ocean access, iconic tennis

Win a two-night stay at this timeless beachfront resort, where luxury matches the elite setting.